Can Blindly Following Polymarket’s Pre-Game Win Probability for NBA Trading Guarantee Steady Profits?

366 0 9

Trading NBA games on Polymarket – perhaps you, like many others, have had this experience: before the game, you see one team’s win probability is significantly higher than their opponent’s, only for them to suddenly collapse in the fourth quarter and get swept away (like the recent Hornets vs. Heat game; that bet made me question my life choices).

Since everyone says Polymarket is a “truth machine,” does that mean I can just mindlessly buy the team with the higher pre-game win probability and easily make money?

To test this hypothesis, I backtested the 1,096 regular-season games of the NBA 2025-26 season. The data reveals the truth –

Mindlessly following the market won’t make you money, but you won’t lose much either. Pre-game probabilities are already fully priced in.

Mindlessly Following the سوق Guarantees Losses

The backtesting strategy used was very simple:

Used the average probability from 3 minutes before the game as the baseline.
Traded $100 per game.
Always bought the side with the “higher win probability.”

Results:

Total cost: $109,600. Total returns: $107,545.2. Net loss: $2,054.
ROI: -1.87%.

This indicates that Polymarket’s prices are quite efficient. The market has already fully priced in the teams’ win probabilities, leaving no “arbitrage” opportunity.

The ROI difference likely stems from other dimensions like transaction costs or emotional premiums. If you insist on “mindlessly buying,” you’d be better off betting against the market, which could yield a 1.87% profit.

The Real Value: Not All Teams Are Created Equal

The above backtest was for the entire set of one thousand games. I further broke down the data from multiple angles, trying to find segments that could break free from market gravity:

By week: Random walk.
By probability: Still a random walk. Betting on pre-game win probabilities of 50%, 60% showed no difference in returns compared to 70%, 80%.
By team: Here, significant differences emerged.

Some teams simply live up to the market’s trust –

When the market thinks they’ll win, they are more likely to actually win.

POR (Trail Blazers): ROI 19%
PHI (76ers): ROI 14%
SAS (Spurs): ROI 12%
LAL (Lakers): ROI 11%
CHA (Hornets): ROI 9%

Why do these teams show such differences? As the author previously had limited knowledge of NBA teams, a hypothesis emerged:

Are they the strongest or weakest teams, leading to high consensus in expectations?

However, verification showed this wasn’t the case. Except for SAS (Spurs), the other four teams were only ranked in the middle to slightly above-average positions.

What about the teams with the best records? The market has already priced them in fully. Mindlessly buying them yields an average ROI of only 2.16%. The pre-game betting win probability contains no “water.”

DET (Pistons): ROI 1%
BOS (Celtics): ROI 4%
NYK (Knicks): ROI 3%
OKC (Thunder): ROI -2%
DEN (Nuggets): ROI -5%

What about the weakest teams?

Here, the results are extremely polarized. For such teams, there are hardly any games where the market favors them to win. For example, the Nets (BKN) had only 7 games with a win probability >50%, winning 5, resulting in a high ROI of 21%. Meanwhile, the Pacers (IND) had 8 games >50%, winning 4, but their ROI was -20%. The sample size is too small to serve as a trading reference.

In other words, theoretically (only theoretically!), POR (Trail Blazers), PHI (76ers), SAS (Spurs), LAL (Lakers), and CHA (Hornets) are the teams the existing data suggests you could follow.

هذا المقال مصدره من الانترنت: Can Blindly Following Polymarket’s Pre-Game Win Probability for NBA Trading Guarantee Steady Profits?

Related: U.S. and Iran Brew New Round of Talks, Bitcoin Recovers Losses Alongside U.S. Stocks

On April 14th, BTC surged from around $70,500, reclaiming the $74,000 level. ETH rose 7.63% to approximately $2,367. The total crypto market cap recovered to about $2.52 trillion, with Bitcoin’s dominance holding steady between 57% and 58%. According to data from Alternative.me, today’s Crypto Fear & Greed Index rose to 21 (yesterday’s reading was 12, indicating “Extreme Fear”), suggesting the market remains in an “Extreme Fear” state. It hit a low of 8 in early April, a rare reading since 2022. In traditional financial markets, the S&P 500 rose 1.02% to 6,886 points, recovering all losses incurred since the US and Israel provoked the Iran conflict and surpassing its February 27th closing level of 6,878 points. The Nasdaq gained 1.23%, marking its ninth consecutive day of gains and its longest…